Parliament OKs legal practice bill


8cab360d884a4ac095d3d92d7cc0f89a
Cape Town – The legal practice bill, which has far-reaching implications for the legal profession, was approved by the National Assembly on Tuesday.

Provisions that were bitterly contested by the profession and opposition parties in extended negotiations remained intact.

The legislation will bring an end to the long tradition of self-regulation by the legal fraternity.

It will replace bar associations with a single council, which the minister of justice can dissolve if he loses confidence in it.

It also allows him to designate three of the 22 members of the council.

The government insists that the 120-clause bill is vital for transforming the legal profession and improving access to justice.

However, it has not managed to allay scepticism, especially since it defers dealing with fee structures that are prohibitive to the poor.

Opening debate on the bill, Justice Minister Jeff Radebe sought to pre-empt criticism by saying the search for agreement on the bill could not continue forever.

The legal profession could not operate in a vacuum where the government’s policy imperatives did not matter.

“The legal profession does not only operate in its own space, but also operates in a space where all of our people, rich or poor, converge in pursuit of justice,” Radebe said.

The laws of the government and those of the profession had to be seen against this background.

Radebe said the government had a legitimate interest in ensuring that constitutional imperatives were complied with.

“The transformation of the legal profession is one of these constitutional imperatives.”

Right to regulate

Parliament had the constitutional right to regulate any profession.

Parliament’s portfolio committee on justice chairperson Luwellyn Landers accused the legal profession of blocking change.

“The bill seeks to transform an extremely conservative and yet fragmented sector of our society…. The legal profession has, until now, successfully resisted change and transformation.”

Radebe said the African National Congress had heeded pleas from the legal profession to drop long-held plans, partly motivated by cost concerns, to do away with the distinction between advocates and attorneys.

The bill, nevertheless, retained a provision that would allow clients to brief advocates directly.

But, the minister conceded, despite such compromises deep disagreement remained over the bill.

“Complete consensus became an impossible task and this is borne out by the almost 20 years of negotiations, but now we have reached the stage where we simply have to forge ahead.”

All opposition parties voted against the bill, which also provides for community service by law graduates, but it was passed with ease thanks to the ANC’s majority.

The Congress of the People’s Luzelle Adams said the ministerial powers in relation to the new council flouted United Nations principles on the independence of the legal profession.

Dire consequences

Democratic Alliance MP Dene Smuts agreed that the bill was “inimical” to the independence of legal practitioners and said this would have dire consequences for the quality of jurisprudence and for society as a whole.

Independent-minded advocates were needed to take on cases that were politically and socially unpopular, and were as needed now to fight injustice as they were in the apartheid era, she argued.

Smuts rubbished the ANC’s claims that transformation would be served by merging the advocates and attorneys’ professions.

She said the ANC was ignoring progress made towards racial representivity, proven by the fact that for the past decade equal numbers of black and white attorneys had been admitted to the bar.

“The advocates’ profession has been sold down the river because the ANC is lost in transformation. We are here legislating for failure and we oppose,” she said.

African Christian Democratic Party MP Steve Smuts said the bill clearly made advocates the junior partners in the new statutory council, and posed the threat of draconian ministerial interference through the council.

He had backed pleas by the DA during drafting that the bill should include a clause on cost disclosure, as it would make it easier for poor South Africans to negotiate fees with lawyers.

However, as the bill stood, this would be deferred to an inquiry, to be conducted by the proposed new council.

Smuts said this would leave South Africans waiting longer for something overdue, and by failing to deal with fees the bill therefore missed its stated aim of improving access to justice.

The legislation makes provision for community service for law graduates, establishes an ombudsman for legal services and sets out more transparent disciplinary processes for legal practitioners.

The Law Society of SA has pleaded for ministerial powers to be limited, and has warned that if the legislation curtails the profession’s independence, the courts will lose their independence.

– SAPA

Huge opposition to McBride choice


10d0bb3c56914c959cafaf59494001b2
Johannesburg – Opposition parties have criticised a decision to recommend former Ekurhuleni metro police chief Robert McBride as head of the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid).

The Democratic Alliance would “vehemently” oppose the appointment in Parliament, MP Dianne Kohler Barnard said on Tuesday.
For more http://www.news24.com

Police inquiry sitting planned in Cape Town


SAPS
Cape Town – The commission of inquiry into allegations of police inefficiency in Khayelitsha, Cape Town, will hold a preliminary sitting this week, commission spokesperson Amanda Dissel said on Tuesday.

She said the sitting would take place at Lookout Hill, in Khayelitsha, at 10:00 on Wednesday.

“Tomorrow’s hearing is going to focus on procedural aspects,” she said at the Harare Library, where the commission had been taking statements from the community.

“[This is] just to check how far we are. How far the various parties are in terms of preparation, and also the various rules and procedures, and how it’s going to be organised.”

The planned sitting followed a court battle between the commission and Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa to establish the validity of the proceedings.

Mthethwa and several other applicants launched urgent proceedings on 8 November last year, claiming the commission had been unconstitutionally and unlawfully appointed by Western Cape Premier Helen Zille.

The applicants wanted the subpoenas sent by the commission to be set aside, arguing that the commission did not have the powers to issue them.

The matter was dismissed by the Western Cape High Court in January.

Mthethwa and the other applicants went to the Constitutional Court and requested leave to appeal the matter.

The Constitutional Court dismissed their application last month.

The commission had continued to collect statements from community members amid the delays.

Dissel said the second preliminary hearing would take place on 25 November.

The commission was hoping to hold public hearings from 21 January until 21 February.

“If we find that the allegations of inefficiency in the police… are valid then we will have a second phase of inquiries starting in March, which is looking at recommendations of how to deal with the problems.”

– SAPA

Dominee’s wife forgives killer son


CrimeTapeSmall
Johannesburg – The widow of a Free State dominee, who was murdered by his adopted son last year, forgave the killer on Tuesday.

However, he should bear the consequences of his actions, Dorothea Brits, 59, told the Harrismith Circuit Court.

Police spokesperson Mmako Mophiring said the matter was postponed to Thursday for sentencing.

The dominee’s son, Martin Brits, 28, appeared with Elliot Mhlambi, 41,

Both have pleaded guilty to killing Dutch Reformed Church Reverend Willem Brits, 60, and his son-in-law Gerhard Vermeulen, 25, in Harrismith on 8 November last year.

Mophiring said it was an emotional day in court as both Brit’s wife and Vermeulen’s mother took the stand to testify.

“Mrs [Dorothea] Brits said she forgave Martin, but added he should face the consequences of his actions,” said Mophiring.

The 59-year-old woman was seriously injured in the attack.

Vermeulen’s mother told the court her son was at the wrong place at the wrong time and had no reason to be killed, said Mophiring.

Brits faced two charges of murder, one of attempted murder and one of robbery.

Mhlambi faced additional charges of possession of an unlicensed firearm and ammunition.

– SAPA

Truck driver convicted for 24 deaths


Court
Mbombela – The driver whose truck collided with a goods train, killing 24 farm workers, has been found guilty of culpable homicide, a Sapa correspondent reported on Tuesday.

George Mandlazi, 33, appeared in the Nelspruit Circuit of the North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria where he explained that while he pleaded not guilty to 24 counts of murder and 23 of attempted murder, he pleaded guilty to 24 counts of culpable homicide and one of negligent driving.

“I was driving the truck on 13 July [2012], I didn’t stop at the crossing, I didn’t see the train or try looking.

“When I was already crossing I heard a hoot and the accident happened, which led to the deaths and injuries, for which I’m very sorry,” his lawyer Melanie Erasmus read from her client’s plea statement.

Mandlazi, who sat quietly in court with his mother, wept as Erasmus read out the statement. When asked if he agreed with the statement, he sobbed and said “I agree”.

The State accepted the plea and withdrew the murder and attempted murder charges, leading Judge Nomsa Khumalo to find him guilty on the lesser charges.

“The accused has been found guilty on 24 counts of culpable homicide and the court further finds you guilty of driving negligently on a public road,” Khumalo said.

His R3 000 bail was extended until Wednesday, when the court would hear sentencing arguments.

Mandlazi was arrested on 13 July 2012, after the truck he was driving collided with a goods train going from Emalahleni to Maputo, Mozambique.

The truck was ferrying 47 seasonal farm workers between Malelane and Hectorspruit when the accident happened at a level crossing.

Nineteen people were killed on the scene. Five others died on their way to hospitals.

Another 23 people were injured.

– SAPA

Info bill goes back to Zuma


zuma
Cape Town – Despite protest from opposition benches, the National Assembly adopted the revised protection of state information bill on Tuesday.

The highly contentious bill will now go back to President Jacob Zuma for assent after 225 MPs voted in favour of the proposed law, and 88 voted against it.

In September, Zuma referred the bill back to the assembly, citing two sections of the bill he deemed unconstitutional.

It was required to correct a cross-reference in section 42 and a punctuation error in section 45 that in effect rendered meaningless a hard-won safeguard on the state’s powers to classify information.

An ad hoc committee then pushed through 30 typographical and grammatical corrections to the bill.

Introducing the revised bill on Tuesday, State Security Minister Siyabonga Cwele said Zuma should be congratulated for identifying the technical errors in the bill.

“What caused the problem first of all… technical errors in the bill sent to him, some of them so material they could be challenged by members of public…,” Cwele said.

Democratic Alliance parliamentary leader Lindiwe Mazibuko said opposition parties would continue in their effort “to not back down in the face of this assault” on democracy.

She singled out the definition of national security in the bill, which was too broad, infringing on South Africans’ right to access to information.

“The DA fully supports correcting anomalies… much more needs to be fixed and the honourable president knows this,” Mazibuko said.

She would again petition the president to not sign the bill into law.

“The DA will not give up fighting this bill. We will not stop until it’s brought completely in line with the Constitution.”

Several other opposition parties held similar views and said the bill remained open to a challenge in the Constitutional Court.

– SAPA

Explosion rocks Eastgate mall


b864956546c44f679003053cebc772be
Johannesburg – A bomb exploded in Bedfordview near the Eastgate shopping mall late Tuesday afternoon, Ekurhuleni metro police said.

“There was a bomb explosion at the corner of Bradford and Nicol roads in Bedfordview,” said police spokesperson Wilfred Kgasago.

He said metro police had no further information at this stage.

Eyewitness News reported the blast was at a shop owned by businessman Radovan Krejcir, who is currently fighting his extradition to the Czech Republic where he is facing a prison sentence.

Sapa was unable to reach Krecjir on his cellphone.

– SAPA

A boy drowns in a quarry in Christiana


1550824704
By Obakeng Maje
Christiana-North West police are investigating a case of inquest after an 8 year-old boy drowned in a quarry today at 15:00 at Gelukspoort Location, near Christiana.

“It is alleged that the boy went swimming with his three friends at a quarry at a known golf course. The police were called and the boy was certified dead at the scene” sergeant Kealeboga Molale said.
Investigation continues.-TDN
Follow us on Twitter@Taung_DailyNews or @IceT_

North West suspects at large after attacking farmer


CrimeTapeSmall
By Obakeng Maje
Klipdrif Farm- A 83 year-old woman allegedly attacked by unknown suspects at Klipdrif farm, near Wolmaransstad on Tuesday, North West police said.
Brigadier Thulani Ngubane said three suspects allegedly attacked a 83 year-old woman and four of her workers at her house in Klipdrift Farm.

“According to the information given, the suspects drove away with the victim and dropped her 200m away from her house and took the bakkie which was later recovered in Ottosdal. She suffered injuries on face and body as she was hit and kicked” Ngubane said.
Police investigation continue.-TDN
Follow us on Twitter@Taung_DailyNews or @IceT_

A farmer burnt with boiling water in robbery


CrimeTapeSmall
By Obakeng Maje
Doringhoek Farm-North West police are investigating a of house robbery and theft after a 50 year-old farmer was allegedly attacked at Doringhoek farm, near Wolmaransstad on Tuesday.

“A 50 year-old man was attacked in his house. According to information received, four suspects gained entrance through the door; they poisoned the dog then handcuffed and burnt the victim with boiling water on the buttocks” Brigadier Thulani Ngubane said.

Ngubane said the suspects allegedly robbed an owner off his 20 diamonds worth R600 000.00, two revolvers and a Toyota bakkie which was recovered at Rooibult farm abandoned.

Police investigations continue and no one has been arrested yet.-TDN
Follow us on Twitter@Taung_DailyNews or @IceT_