By OBAKENG MAJE
30 March 2026 – A man (57) has been sentenced to life imprisonment by the Pretoria High Court for killing his wife. On the night of 12 October 2024, the deceased, Theonette Smith and the accused, Peter Johannes Smith were consuming alcohol and celebrating Smith’s new work appointment at their place of residence in Brits.
The National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) regional spokesperson, Lumka Mahanjana said while celebrating, an argument ensued between the two and during the argument, the deceased physically assaulted Smith by slapping him. Mahanjana said in response, Smith assaulted the deceased by slapping her multiple times on her head and the deceased fell on the floor and died.
“Thereafter, Smith left the deceased lying on the floor in their living area and went to sleep. The following morning, Smith took the body of the deceased, placed it in his car and dumped the half-naked body of the deceased in a nearby veld.
“Smith then went to the Brits Police Station to report his wife missing and while opening a missing person’s report, a police officer received a phone call from a community member stating that they had found a half-naked body at a veld,” she said.
Mahanjana further said the police then took Smith to the veld and on arrival Smith identified the dead body as his wife. She added that while at the veld, the police noticed blood stains in Smith’s car and requested him to take them to his place of residence.
“On arrival, the police found blood stains on Smith’s couch and living room. Smith was then arrested at his place of residence and has been in custody since the NPA successfully opposed his release on bail.
“During trial proceedings, Smith pleaded not guilty to the charge of murder. However, the state prosecutor, advocate Vusimuzi Tshabalala, presented compelling evidence, including expert testimony from a pathologist, which proved the accused’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt,” said Mahanjana.
She said during sentencing proceedings, the defence requested the court to deviate from imposing the prescribed minimum sentence of life imprisonment, citing that Smith is a first-time offender, had recently secured permanent employment as a teacher and holds a black belt in karate. Mahanjana said the defence further argued that he did not cause any serious injuries to the deceased and that he was under the influence of alcohol at the time of the offence.
“Tshabalala opposed this submission, arguing that Smith was aware of the deceased’s underlying medical condition and had a duty to protect her as his spouse. Instead, he subjected her to violence, ultimately causing her death.
“The state further submitted that Smith demonstrated a lack of remorse, attempted to mislead the police and degraded the dignity of the deceased by disposing of her half-naked body in a veld,” she said.
Mahanjana said Tshabalala also read a Victim Impact Statement (VIS) facilitated by Court Preparation Officer Lebogang Lebese, where the daughter of the deceased expressed how her psychological and physical wellbeing has deteriorated after her mother died and that she has lost her support system. She said in delivering judgment, acting Judge Melissa Jordan agreed with the state’s submissions, noting that Smith had abused a position of trust.
“The court found that, as a trained karate practitioner, he possessed the knowledge and capability to inflict harm. The judge further rejected the argument that alcohol influenced his actions, noting that Smith had indicated he would have acted similarly even if sober.
“The court found no substantial and compelling circumstances to justify a deviation from the prescribed minimum sentence and accordingly imposed life imprisonment,” said Mahanjana.
She said the NPA reiterates its commitment to combating Gender-Based Violence (GBV) and ensuring that perpetrators of crimes against vulnerable persons are held accountable. Mahanjana said he was further sentenced to five years imprisonment for defeating the ends of justice.
“The court ordered that the five-year sentence run concurrently with the life sentence,” she said.
The Guardian 